Wisconsin State Journal May 25, 2012
Black Earth pastor gets 2 years in prison in child abuse caseA Dane County, WI, pastor was convicted of conspiracy to commit child abuse. He had been preaching to members of the Aleitheia Bible Church of Black Earth, WI, that the Bible prescribes corporal punishment for disobedient children. What preacher Philip Caminiti advocated was the use of wooden spoons or wooden dowels to "spank" children. This left persistent red marks or bruises, which is how Wisconsin differentiates between spanking and child abuse. Caminiti apparently advocated this concerning children as young as one-and-a-half months. Wisconsin police intervened in 2010 to put a stop to this practice.
In addition to his prison term, Caminiti will be on probation for six years, during which his contact with his own children will be limited. He is also ordered to have no contact with Aleitheia Bible Church and to have no leadership role in any church.
His brother, church elder
John Caminiti, was sentenced in 2011 to a year in prison and seven years of "extended supervision" for shunning his teenage son because the son had feelings that he described as "pressure and fear." He also struck with a wooden dowel other children, including those of other members of the church, for being grumpy or disobedient.
Eight members of the church face child abuse charges.
No Longer Qivering discusses the case of Lori Wick, an author of "historical Christian novels," who supposedly provides substantial financial support to the church and is one of those accused of child abuse.
The right wing and the evangelical/fundamentalist press caught on yesterday to this matter and are aghast.
Free Republic has a thread, as do
Infowars and
The Church Report.
I am at a loss as to what I think about this. The pastor was advocating what is legally defined in Wisconsin as child abuse. This resulted in incidents perpetrated by members of the church. Other pastors (e.g., Wiley Drake) have called upon god to strike down President Obama, with no results (yet). Is that why Drake still preaches, while Caminiti sits in prison?
Where does freedom of religion end and engaging in a conspiracy to violate the law begin?
According to Christianity Today, a trial judge spoke to this:
Quote:
A Wisconsin trial court judge denied a motion to dismiss charges against a convicted pastor who instructed his church members to use wooden rods to spank misbehaving children, some as young as two months old.
...
Caminiti argued the convictions violate his right to religious freedom. But Circuit Judge Maryann Sumi disagreed, stating that though Caminiti had “a sincerely held religious belief” to use a rod to discipline young children, he failed to prove Wisconsin’s child abuse statue “places a burden” on that belief.
“Scripture doesn't specify how and when the rod should be used,” Sumi ruled.
In January,
Christianity Today examined arguments for and against corporal punishment, as the misuse of biblical teaching on discipline can have deadly consequences.
I do not see why what the Bible specifies and does not specify is relevant to a decision to dismiss the motion. The Bible specifies stoning to death disobedient sons; would Judge Sumi have ruled in favor of a pastor who taught that?