Hi, I'm a long-time lurker that usually leaves the posting to the more knowledgeable, but I recently read something that I thought was interesting and thought I'd bring it up. Also, please feel free to move if this is in the wrong thread - wasn't quite sure where it best fits.
Anyways, I was reading a relatively new book on the assassination and death of President Garfield ("Destiny of the Republic" by Candice Millard - highly recommended if you're into those types of books) and I was struck by the similarities between Garfield's assassin (Charles Guiteau) and birthers. I have always seen the birthers as simply annoying wingnuts who posed no actual danger. But the similarities with Guiteau, and his eventual escalation to actually pulling a trigger, frightened me.
Like the birthers, Guiteau imagined himself as far greater than he actually was. While in life he failed at many things (including failing at practicing law after a dubious bar exam... sound familiar?) even in the face of all his struggles, he believed that God had a destiny for him. He also believed that others thought he was a great as he saw himself, and therefore couldn't understand why he was continually rejected. In other words, he was so mentally detached from reality that the normal actions of government officials (in his case, not appointing him ambassador to France) enraged him enough to attempt to kill the president.
I think one paragraph from the book shows his remarkable similarity to the birthers:
Quote:
When [Guiteau] had first submitted his application for an appointment [to be an ambassador], he had been told, as was every office seeker, that it would be put on file and considered. "In the majority of cases there was not the slightest possibility of any position being granted," a While House employee who helped shepherd callers through the president's anteroom later explained. "It was just the usual human method of saving trouble and avoiding a scene." Guiteau, however, believed that the president was carefully studying his application and that his appointment was only a matter of time. When, after handing the doorman a note for Garfield one day, he was told, "The President says it will be impossible to see you to-day," he seized on the word "to-day." This was Garfield's way, he thought, of telling him that, "as soon as he got Walker (the current consul-general to France) out of the way gracefully then I would be given the office."
To me that paragraph could, with a few small changes, describe any number of birthers - those who, when judges completely reject their reasoning, they think are just "signaling" to them or "setting up an appeal"; statements by Hawaiian officials that to any normal person clearly state that Obama was born in Hawaii, but who used some strange word combination (e.g., "Natural Born American Citizen") that birthers jump on as crucial. I'm not sure if this is just a coincidence, or if it shows that birthers suffer from the same type of strong delusion that Guiteau suffered from. Either way, since Guiteau's mental illness led to the death of a president, I thought the similarities would be interesting to bring up.
The one encouraging element in the comparison is that Guiteau's attempt at the president's life was so amateur that any security at all would have prevented the assassination. He was so delusional that he was really only capable of acting on his own and wasn't smart enough to plan something clever. Of course, in the 1800's, when presidents didn't have even a single bodyguard, that was enough. With today's phalanx of secret service surrounding President Obama, I'm confident that someone as delusional as Guiteau would never be able to pull something off.
Still, the substantial similarities between Guiteau's delusions and the birthers' delusions startled me.