TollandRCR wrote:
I was pleased to find a Borders in Singapore and slightly surprised to find the red censor's mark in every single book. The censorship was primarily political, not moral, even though some critical political books were allowed in. That store had already taken to gimmicks, raffling off a Mercedes A-class when I was last there. The estimated value was Singapore $97,000. It is very expensive to own a car in Singapore.
A couple of comments.
As you noted, censorship in Singapore is primarily political, although the MDA does also frown upon pornography. Interestingly, and in my opinion properly, they also take a very dim view of hate speech of any kind. This place would tear itself apart quickly if there weren't measures in place to keep three different races and four very different religions from attacking each other. A Christian pastor made some denigrating comments about Buddhism a while back, which brought not only immediate chastising by the entire religious community, but also a
rebuke by the government (the ISD is the same group that can detain people indefinitely under the Internal Security Act). Personally, my biggest complaint about censorship is that is prevents me from easily using things like e-books. I have to use an Amazon account I set up while in the US, because e-books or other downloadable media can't be sold in Singapore.
You're also right that cars are very expensive in Singapore, and actually a bit more expensive than your example. A typical Mercedes A-Class here is about
$160K without COE (Certificate of Entitlement - a ten year license to own a car). COE prices go up and down with supply and demand, and right now a COE for this type of car is about $65K. When Michael Fay was caned here for vandalizing cars in the Orchard Rd area, a lot of folks in the US didn't realize just how much economic damage he and his friends were doing (they were egging and spray painting cars).
Borders isn't doing well here, either. I would guess that you visited the their Wheelock Place location (corner of Orchard Rd and Paterson/Scotts), which was their flagship store in Singapore and which is now
closed. It was a nice store, but it didn't have nearly the selection that Kinokuniya has next door in Ngee Ann City, and as you noted, a lot of what they carried was dreck. Rent in that area is quite expensive (~2 1/2 Mercedes/Month), and my observations were that the casual browsing atmosphere that helps sales in the US worked against it here - People often spent a lot of time in the store without buying anything. The magazine section was particularly bad for this. Add high costs, lower sales, Internet shopping, and e-books, and things don't look too good for them.
All is not lost in the bookstore world, however. If you're ever back here and are interested in a really neat local book store, wander up Orchard Rd to Tanglin Shopping Centre and check out
Select Books. It specializes in Asian, and in particular SE Asian topics, including a lot about local politics. It's one of my favorite places to visit on a Saturday afternoon (and yes, I usually buy something

).