neonzx wrote:
I had not followed the show, but took your advice and watched the pilot and episodes 2 and 3 via Netflix streaming today. I'm a huge fan of zombie films, but I'm not sure this series is going to hold my interest. The "walkers" (zombies) are merely a backdrop to the main drama themes involving the living.
I dislike that they do not present certain elements of the show as realistic, starting with deputy Rick waking from his coma after not being tended to at least for several weeks (the wilted and dried flowers). The scene where deputy Shane delivers those flowers suggests Rick had been in a coma for quite a long time, yet, after a couple minutes out of bed, he has no problem getting around. I guess the writers have never heard of muscle atrophy.
I'll watch the rest of season one and see how it goes. I see IMDB viewers have very highly rated it so perhaps I need to give it a chance?
It's definitely worth a watch, and one must nearly always suspend disbelief at the usually absurd scenarios that lead to a zombie apocalypse and somehow have nobody but people who have never seen a zombie film in them as survivors. The first half of the second season, which just finished, will annoy you even more if the current level of living human drama is already annoying you. However, the mid-season finale was phenomenal.
Interestingly, it's the characters who start out least sympathetic in the beginning who end up the fan favorites by this point in the series, and the initially sympathetic characters end up being annoying jerks at least some of the time. One common fan criticism is too much drama, too few zombies. In the second season, be prepared to hit fast forward a few times if you utterly cannot stand emo bullshit and stilted dialogue. There are also a number of irritating story arcs.
I can't really spoil since even some viewers of the show here haven't yet seen the truly great mid-season finale (they split the season into two parts and the rest starts airing in February). All I'll say is hooray Daryl Dixon.
Other gripes with the show I have are the abysmal treatment of the female characters who really have promise, the use of minority characters like T-Dog and Glenn as a prop and zombie-bait, respectively, and downright ridiculous dialogue.
This criticism aside, though, I never even watch a show long enough to have any criticism of it unless it's one of the shows I actually follow. Currently, I don't have any such show until it come back in February, and the only other currently ongoing show I watch is Breaking Bad. I am a complete zombie freak, though, so I am probably biased and AMC has a sucker in me.
The first half-season is, IMO, really good. The second season stumbles and fumbles, but ultimately comes through in the last couple episodes. I thought it was a particularly bad idea to start the series with a 90 minute episode when they only had 60 minutes of material. I think I'll stop now, because I don't want my nitpicking to turn anyone off what is at least so far a pretty solid show.