TexasFilly wrote:
Well, Poutine, one may think about all of those things prior to stepping into the batter's box. Once in that box, baseball becomes a game of reaction. Situational awareness, is, of course critical, but successful hitters see the ball, and hit the ball. The player who engages in thinking at the plate, well, he's probably going to go to law school.

The ghost of Ty Cobb shall now rise up in my defense:
Quote:
The first item in scientific hitting is bat selection. For a swing hitter (one who starts his bat far back and complete his swing with a full follow-through) I suggest a bat with the feel on the light side. For the one with a shorter, more compact swing, the bat should feel slightly heavy.
Next comes position. Never copy a batter with an exaggerated crouch. THe best hitters stand up and have the look of a good hitter. In case your normal stance becomes uncomfortable while awaiting the delivery, breaking of the knees (a dip or slight squat) will relieve this. But of course you must always come back to the position first assumed.
The space between feet should be measured by how well balanced you feel. This will measure about 14 inches for players of average height. But don't think of this kind of thing in inches. Just stand so you feel balanced, and can step either into the pitch or away.
If you are able to put a little extra weight on the front foot and still feel balanced to step either way, so much the better. The ability to do this will assure proper stride and, when swinging, will bring the body and arms up to the ball more automatically. I emphasize the value of proper striding because over-striding is fatal. It causes uppercutting and fly balls, upsets coordination and costs freedom to step in or out.
A righthanded batter attempting to hit the ball to right, or opposite (from normal) field should use the closed stance. That means the left foot is about 4 inches closer to the plate than the right. Hitting to left field, his front foot is about 4 inches away, or in open stance. The straightaway hitter lines up both feet with the line of the pitch.
I always had trouble hitting lefthanded pitching, especially curve ballers, until I went to the back line of the batter's box. [highlight]That gave me the benefit of the extra inches from the pitcher, and the split-second extra time in which to judge the pitch[/highlight].
Keep your arms, particularly the elbows, away from the body. This insures freedom of swing. I also recommend the elbow nearer the pitcher be raised and exaggerated. This, plus a slight bending of the body from the waist up, will give you better body balance, insures automatically hitting the ball out in front and brings your eyes in better focusing position.
Do all your "fixing" as to grip and stance before delivery, then forget about your swing. Watch the pitcher's every move and never let your eye leave the ball. Many batters are thrown out by a half-step, so once you've hit the ball, run with all the speed you have, no matter where the ball goes.
Ty Cobb. Famous Slugger Year Book, 1950 (emphasis added).
Do you "think" while that pitch is coming in? Depends on your definition of "think." You still need to figure out whether it's a curveball, fastball, knuckler, change-up, slider, or split-fingered, and while you're doing that you need to figure out whether it's in the strike zone. These are things you begin to calculate as the pitcher winds up, long after you've stepped into the batter's box.